History of Titanium | Grades and Sources of Titanium | 3-2.5 Tubing Comparison
Resiliency, Flexibility & Fatigue | Titanium Use & Abuse
Ovalizing and Tapering Tubes | Engineering Principles of Butting Tubes
Tapering vs. Butting | Welding | Anodizing
Future of Titanium | Glossary
3-2.5 Ti Comparison with Other Materials
Titanium Parts

3-2.5 Ti Comparison with Other Materials

Steel | Aluminum | Metal-Matrix Composites
Titanium Metal Matrix Composites | Beryllium
Carbon Fiber | Carbon Wrapped Titanium and Aluminum
Honeycomb Reinforced Titanium

Carbon Fiber

Carbon fiber is a blanket term for a wide variety of carbon-impregnated polyesters, graphite fibers, and polymerized carbon fibers that are used within a matrix of adhesive to create a clothlike structural material.

Within the family of fibers considered appropriate for bicycle frame use, the raw fibers' stiffness-to-weight ratio is roughly 3.5 times higher than 3-2.5 titanium. The ultimate tensile strength is roughly 70% higher.

However, these figures apply only to the raw fiber strand, before it is impregnated by and retained within an epoxy resin matrix. The epoxy adhesive's structural properties are significantly lower. Moreover, epoxy normally occupies 50% or more of the cross-sectional area of a sheet of carbon fiber cloth. This ratio of resin to carbon must be maintained to hold the fibers together; a lower epoxy content reduces the fiber weave's layer-to-layer shear strength. A 50% volume of adhesive reduces the finished product's strength-to-weight ratio by a factor of two.

In addition, carbon fiber is anisotropic, which means that it displays directional properties. For example, a fiber with a modulus of 20,000 ksi when measured longitudinally will have, at best, a transverse modulus of 4,000 ksi. Similarly, the ultimate tensile strength may measure 220 ksi longitudinal, but will be, at best, 10 ksi transverse.

This anisotropic property can be exploited beneficially in some structures, such as leaf springs. However, bicycle tubes must be able to carry stress loads in many planes at once-in tension, compression, fully reversed bending and clockwise and counterclockwise torsion. Thus, it is virtually impossible to utilize anisotropy to any significant extent in a frame.

In addition to the modest structural properties displayed by the epoxy resin, carbon fiber has extremely low ductility and poor abrasion resistance. Historically, low ductility in those bicycle frames that do not use separate lugs has led to joint failure and stress cracking. Abrasion is a particularly thorny problem since composites are notch-sensitive, such that even minute inconsistencies in the material can develop into large cracks, eventually leading to failure.

Abrasion problems can be reduced at the cost of added weight by a protective skin or veil of fiberglass or, at higher cost and somewhat greater strength, Kevlar fiber, but the abrasion resistance of these and similar polyester and aramid fibers is also low. Abrasion and impact damage can be repaired with epoxy-based fillers and additional cloth. However, since the integrity of the structure is dependent upon continuous fibers in tension, the strength of the repaired area will be lower than the original material, and the weight of the repair will be higher.


© Merlin 2001. All rights reserved.